All coins

Reporting · policy

Fourth Circuit upholds denial of Kalshi injunction in Maryland dispute

A divided panel in the Fourth Circuit held that Maryland sports-wagering rules apply to Kalshi contracts, with one judge dissenting.

By Dextape Desk1 min read

Share

Editorial illustration for regulation coverageEditorial illustration for regulation coverage

Quick take

  1. The Fourth Circuit affirmed the denial of Kalshi's preliminary injunction, holding that Maryland's sports-wagering rules apply to its contracts.
  2. On the swaps question, Thacker found the contracts are not swaps while Benjamin, dissenting, found they are.
  3. Because the ruling covers only the injunction, the final merits remain undecided and the circuits remain divided.

Unchained reported that the Fourth Circuit has affirmed the denial of a preliminary injunction Kalshi sought against Maryland. The unsigned per curiam opinion is dated November 18, and judges Gregory and Thacker voted to affirm, while judge Benjamin dissented. The court's decision holds that Maryland's sports-wagering rules apply to Kalshi contracts.

Thacker concluded that the contracts are not swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act. Benjamin, dissenting, argued that the contracts are swaps and fall under CFTC jurisdiction. Kalshi's argument has also been rejected by the Sixth and Ninth Circuits, while the Third Circuit ruled in Kalshi's favor.

The conflict started on April 7, 2025, when a cease-and-desist letter from Maryland reached Kalshi. Kalshi sued on April 21, 2025, and Judge Abelson denied its request for an injunction on August 1, 2025. Nevada, Ohio and 36 other states sided with Maryland.

The ruling addresses only the preliminary injunction and does not decide the final merits of the case. Its effect is limited to the injunction request, while the swaps question remains contested across circuits.

Sources

Machine-written from the publishers’ reports and checked against them · How Dextape writes

About the author

Dextape DeskEditors

The Dextape Desk signs Dextape's briefs, market reports and news stories, each machine-written from the named sources and checked by code before it appears.

Share this story